Dentist explaining different types of treatment as per new informed consent standards after the Montgomery Ruling.

The Montgomery Ruling changed the standards for informed consent in the UK forever. Where a medical professional was previously required to adhere to Bolam Test standards when informing patients, patients must now be informed of all material risks as a result of this ruling. Let’s take a closer look into the impact of this shift in consent standards on UK dentistry and indemnity. 

At a Glance: 

The key impacts of the Montgomery Ruling on informed consent:

  1. A shift away from the Bolam Test when evaluating what information to provide patients with
  2. New standards of informed consent
  3. Fresh focus on long-standing GMC guidance
  4. Increased indemnity risk of failure-to-inform claims

 

A Closer Look at Informed Consent as per the Montgomery Ruling

  • A shift away from the Bolam Test when evaluating what information to provide patients with

Under Bolam Test standards, a dentist’s actions were evaluated as to whether a responsible group of dental colleagues would have acted in the same way. If these colleagues would have taken the same course of action, then the dentist was legally defended against negligence allegations. It was up to the dentist to decide what risks to disclose to a patient based on what this body of dental colleagues with industry expertise would disclose.

The Montgomery Ruling, however, changed the way that UK dentists select what information to provide patients with and which risks are worth addressing. A dentist must now inform a patient of any and all material risk associated with a procedure as well as alternative courses of treatment, a clear shift from informing in line with industry standards and experience on how likely a risk is. 

  • New standards of informed consent

With the Montgomery Ruling changing the standards of information that a dentist must provide a patient with, this has consequences on informed consent. Informed consent means that a patient must be made aware of all aspects of a procedure, from the risks to the recovery times, and the new standard of information that must be provided to patients has heightened the standards for informed consent.

A dentist can no longer argue that they did not inform a patient of procedural risks because, historically, dental colleagues have found these risks to be too minimal to mention. A dentist must now inform patients of all material risks before consent is obtained.

  • Fresh focus on long-standing GMC guidance

The Montgomery Ruling also placed a fresh focus on the importance of adhering to long-standing General Medical Council (GMC) guidance that was already in place before the hearing occurred. The GMC’s decision making and consent guidance of 2020 explains in paragraph 23 that any expected side effects and all risks of harm must be explained to the patient before treatment, no matter how big, small or unlikely they are. This guidance, though since revised, has stood long before the Montgomery Ruling but it becomes even more important as a result.

  • Increased indemnity risk of failure-to-inform claims

Another key impact of the Montgomery Ruling on informed consent in dentistry is that there is a heightened risk of patients claiming that they have not been sufficiently informed of risks should a procedure go wrong. This increase in indemnity risk is the exact reason a trusted dental indemnity provider like Densura is a necessity in modern UK dentistry. Access to Densura’s dento-legal advisors is invaluable when navigating these failure-to-inform claims or avoiding them completely through adhering to legal advice on what risks to inform a patient of.

 

FAQs About the Montgomery Ruling

Q: When did the case take place?

A: The Montgomery Ruling took place in 2015 in London’s Supreme Court of the United Kingdom.

Q: What was the cause of the case?

A: Nadine Montgomery’s son was born with cerebral palsy as a result of shoulder dystocia during birth and claimed that she was not informed of this as a potential risk before birth, launching a case as a result that she would later win.

Q: How has informed consent changed as a result of the Montgomery Ruling?

A: Dentists in the UK may no longer choose to exclude potential risks when discussing procedures with patients simply because they are minimal or dental industry standards would view them as acceptable to exclude. They must now unpack all material risks with a patient before a procedure.

Ready to Get Started?

Densura UK is here for you should claims arise as a result of these heightened standards of informed consent. Reach out to our team and request a quote today!

If you have any questions before you begin, our team is happy to talk you through the process. We understand the dental profession, and we’re here to make sure you’re properly protected.

Densura provides professional indemnity tailored to UK dental professionals. All quotes are subject to individual assessment and underwriting.

 

Written and reviewed on 30 October 2026

Ready to make the switch?

Get in touch if you’d like to switch from your current dental indemnity provider. Our team of experts will be happy to offer you a free, bespoke quote.

The Indemnity Risks of Dental Sedation & How to Stay Compliant

The Indemnity Risks of Dental Sedation & How to Stay Compliant

Dental sedation carries unique indemnity risks in the UK. There are various protocols and precautions that must be followed when it comes to dental sedation and respecting these guidelines is key in staying compliant. From ensuring consent is obtained to practicing...